First published 20 December 2020. Updated on 7 November 2026 for the Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026, which came into force on 21 February 2026. Please contact us before relying on it for your own situation.

Informal conversation or notification
Misconduct can be difficult to identify and deal with. The most important part is to act in good faith, and clearly distinguish between the type of misconduct you are dealing with, as this will ultimately determine the process you need to follow. Click here to learn more about the different types of misconduct.
If it’s minor, you can choose to have an informal conversation. It is still important that you document it and let the employee know that if it happens again, you’ll be starting a formal disciplinary process.
If it’s more serious, let them know that you’ll be investigating the issue, and will meet with them again after investigating. It is important to not expect an employee to comment on anything you deem as serious misconduct before you have an opportunity to share with them the information you are relying on, and allow them sufficient time to secure a support person and review the information.
Meeting invites for serious misconduct should:
- Be in writing (a letter or e-mail is sufficient)
- Include the reason for the meeting, which is to discuss the allegations of serious misconduct
- Where possible, any information that you may be relying on (such as clauses in their contract, processes, complaints from customers or other employees etc.)
- Inform them of their right to bring a support person with them
- State whether or not their position may be affected as a result of the process (not the meeting – there is a process to be followed, and completed)
- Allow them sufficient notice to go through any information you provided, and to secure a support person if necessary (how much time is reasonable depends on the circumstances and the amount of information, and be flexible if their support person is not available immediately)
- Because this is the first step, you should inform them that the investigation may lead to the termination of their employment
- You also need to let them know that they are not expected to respond to the allegations yet, as they will be given an opportunity to review any information or documentation you uncover as part of your investigation, and time to prepare, before being asked to comment. If they want to give an initial account anyway, you can note it without treating it as their final response
If you do not allow them a genuine opportunity to prepare and find support, your process may be deemed unfair. We know you want to get through this as nobody enjoys these types of conversations, but remember that they are likely very stressed and worried, and as part of your obligation to act in good faith, you need to be fair and reasonable. That means going through a proper investigation before meeting again to share and discuss your findings.
Suspension
For instances of serious misconduct where it is unsafe to allow the employee to continue working under any circumstances you should first check to see whether your employment agreement has a suspension clause, and if so, follow the steps set out in the clause. Even if no clause exists, you can still consider suspension, but in either instance, you should:
- First inform the employee that you are considering suspension (which should ordinarily be on full pay – unpaid suspension is only an option if the employment agreement expressly allows it and it is reasonable in the circumstances – and for a defined, reasonable period)
- Give them an opportunity to comment on the proposal to suspend them (they may have suggestions that could allow them to continue working in a different capacity)
- Give them a reasonable time to respond – how long depends on the urgency, the concerns and their ability to get advice
- Do not predetermine that you will suspend (by shutting off their system access, phone, etc.)
- Only once they respond and you have considered their input, can you suspend if that is still the only plausible way forward
In exceptional cases, such as an immediate risk to safety, an urgent interim suspension without prior consultation may be justified – but you must still act fairly and reasonably, and give the employee a chance to comment as soon as possible.
Investigate the allegation or actions
If necessary, depending on the nature of the misconduct, get written statements from witnesses, with details like:
- the date of the incident
- what time it happened
- a description of the alleged behaviour.
Tell the witnesses that their relevant evidence, and ordinarily their identity, will be shared with the employee you’re investigating so that the employee can respond. If there is a genuine confidentiality issue, take advice – the employee must still get a fair opportunity to answer the allegations. If you witnessed it yourself, document your own statement of the event, and get statements from other witnesses if possible.
Do not predetermine any outcome, any action that may be perceived as predetermination could land you in hot water. It is important to keep an open mind at all times. The Employment Relations Authority (ERA) and Employment Court will look at the actions you took and what a reasonable employer could have done in all the circumstances, taking into account the resources available to the employer at the time the action occurred.
Check documentation
Check relevant company policies and your employee’s employment agreement for clauses outlining unacceptable behaviour. This will let you confirm, if the allegations are proven, that they breached your rules, policies, or employment agreement.
Put the allegations and evidence in writing
Set out the allegations and your evidence in a letter, for the employee to comment on. The letter should include:
- details of the allegations (including any witness statements)
- excerpts of the relevant clauses in the employment agreement or company policies that may have been breached if the allegations are made out
- a date on which you want to meet with the employee to discuss the allegations (let them know they can bring a support person or representation)
- the consequences of what may happen if the allegations are upheld (for example, a written warning or in serious cases, termination)
Meet with the employee
Arrange a meeting with the employee – you can both have a support person there if you want to.
Set out the reason why you called the meeting. Explain the allegations against the employee and the possible consequences if they are made out.
Give your employee the chance to tell their side of the story. At the end of the meeting, let them know how long you’ll take to consider the situation, and when/how you’ll inform them of the outcome.
Don’t make a decision without taking the time to genuinely consider their explanation. A fair and reasonable employer is obligated to act in good faith, which means being constructive and communicative in maintaining the employment relationship, and therefore it is of the utmost importance to take the time to think about it, and then think about it some more.
Make your decision
Consider all the evidence and decide what the outcome will be. When you have made a preliminary decision you should discuss this with the employee and ask for their response. When you have considered their response, then only you can make a final decision. You can:
- dismiss the allegations
- give an informal warning
- give a formal warning
- if the conduct is serious enough, give a final written warning
- if the conduct is serious misconduct and dismissal is justified, dismiss the employee – either without notice (summary dismissal) or with notice or pay in lieu of notice (this will depend on the seriousness of the conduct as well as what is set out in your employment contract/policies)
When deciding how to deal with the behaviour, consider what an objectively reasonable employer could do in your situation.
Detail your findings in a letter to your employee, noting what clauses or policies have been breached. State what may happen if the behaviour is repeated.
If the misconduct is repeated
If you witness or receive allegations of further misconduct by that employee, you’ll need to repeat the process above – whether it’s for the same behaviour, or something different. Be careful about relying on earlier warnings for a different kind of misconduct. Whether you can depends on what those warnings said – a warning should state clearly what further conduct may lead to dismissal – and on the circumstances. Any decision to dismiss must still follow a fair process, in accordance with the relevant policies or employment agreement clauses.
If the misconduct is proved again, depending on the type of misconduct you can:
- consider whether the consequence stated in your last valid warning is still appropriate – it does not follow automatically, and depends on the new conduct, what the warning covered, whether it is still current and the employee's response
- issue another formal warning (there’s no limit to how many warnings you can give – it depends on the type of misconduct)
- issue a final written warning, stating that if the behaviour is to happen again, they may be dismissed
- if the misconduct is serious enough or has repeated often, you may want to consider dismissing your employee.
Always document any related conversations. You may not be able to rely on previous misconduct if it was not documented properly.
What changed on 21 February 2026
The Employment Relations Amendment Act 2026 changed how dismissals are assessed and what remedies are available. The main points for employers:
- The justification test (s 103A). The Authority and the Court still ask whether you investigated adequately for your resources, raised your concerns with the employee, gave them a reasonable opportunity to respond and genuinely considered their response. They now also consider whether the employee obstructed any of those steps (s 103A(3)(e)). A flaw in the process does not by itself make a dismissal unjustified unless it resulted in the employee being treated unfairly (s 103A(5)).
- Contributing conduct (ss 123B and 123C). If the employee's own actions contributed to the situation and amount to serious misconduct, no remedy can be awarded. If the employee's actions contributed but are not serious misconduct, reinstatement and compensation for hurt and humiliation or loss of benefit are not available, and other remedies can be reduced by up to 100% (s 124(2)). The employee's action must be blameworthy, not merely a cause of what happened – ordinary underperformance is not usually treated that way. The Employment Court has held that s 123C does not apply to proceedings that had already started before 21 February 2026 (The Board of Trustees v LGY [2026] NZEmpC 46 at [8]), and the Authority has taken the same approach to ss 123B, 123C and 124 (OAS v JIK Ltd [2026] NZERA 474 at [62]–[63]). How the new remedy rules apply to events before that date but filed later is not yet settled.
- High earners (ss 67I, 113A and 113B). An employee whose annual remuneration is $200,000 or more cannot bring a personal grievance about the dismissal – whether framed as an unjustified dismissal or as an unjustified disadvantage relating to the dismissal. Other grievances, such as discrimination or sexual or racial harassment, remain available. When deciding whether to dismiss such an employee, the employer does not have to give the usual information and opportunity to comment, or written reasons if asked. None of this applies if the employment agreement opts out in writing (s 67J), and transitional rules protect some existing employees for up to 12 months from 21 February 2026.
For most employees, none of this removes the need for good reasons and a fair process. The Authority and the Court still look at both what you decided and how you went about it (s 103A), and the changes to remedies only apply once they have made findings about the employee's conduct.
Get in touch
Explore how we can assist your business – phone or email us.
